A bottle of white. A bottle of red. Or how about 100 labels from Veneto winemakers?
In the three days I spent traipsing across Emilia Romagna, the gastronomic heart and soul of Italy, I ate very good - nay, excellent - tortellini, Bolognese sauce, Parmagiana Reggiano, proscuitto, salami, pecorino, extra virgin olive oil, crostoli, osso bucco, ravioli and, yes, bologna. Accompanied by lambrusco, the region's famed fizzy red wine, this cuisine and vino went hand in hand like Gene Kelly and Frank Sinatra hustling together "On The Town". As I was leaving for Venice, the Emilia Romagna locals said, with a tiny bit of pity playing at the corners of their lips, "It is a very beautiful town, but..." But what? "But if you like seafood, then maybe it is OK."
That's a polite way of saying that Venice isn't known for serving particularly memorable cuisine, by Italian standards. It's famous for polenta and squid ink pasta, but nobody goes to Venice to eat, particularly if you've already gotten your fill on the streets of Carnavale.
Who cares. I fell in love with Venice the minute I stepped out of the train station and the Grand Canal yawned and serpentined its way from my feet to forever. That first afternoon, I explored the old Jewish ghetto and the Cannaregio quarter, and forgot where I was, really. Venice is a timeless trap you never want to find your way out of. It's like "Hotel California" written by Vivaldi. I ate a very local Venetian dinner at Antica Adelaide, which has been around since the 1700s, setting me back even farther from the present.
But I didn't forget a tweet from my friend Howard (@hriefs), a fine gentleman who prefers the finer things in life (with the exception of the Cubs). Basically, I got the sense that if I didn't eat at an osteria called Alle Testiere, I was not to leave Italy. I hadn't realized how infamous it was on the gourmand pantheon - you know, the kind of place where if you mention "Venice" and true foodies only need to exchange eye contact to know they are thinking of the same place. Howard mentioned that reservations were direly necessary, so the next late afternoon, as I was (unintentionally) going in circles around San Marco Square, I decided I better go by to secure a spot for dinner.
This is how you get to Alle Testiere. You find your way to Salizzada San Lio, a major thoroughfare, which in Venetian terms means three people can walk, quite easily, side by side and not have one on either end scraping a shoulder on an old brick wall. Then suddenly, you'll find yourself at a ponte at Calle Bande, and get a strange feeling that you're in the wrong direction. So, turn back and go back down San Lio in the other direction before hitting another canale - at this point, you might want to tear your map up. Repeat this a few times, before realizing that one of the unmarked little calles is indeed Mondo Nuovo, where Alle Testiere awaits behind a green door and curtained windows. There is absolutely nothing to highlight that this is a restaurant revered by the New York Times and other important food authorities, so you might want to gingerly push the door open while tripping on the inconspicuous step. But, you'll know that you've arrived because Marcello is there waiting in the middle of just 22 settings on nine tables in one 10-meter-by-six-meter room. He'll inform you that there are only two seatings each evening, but thank goodness! There is a little corner table he can give you for the 7pm.
When you return at the appointed time, having fought off cat calls and wolf whistles from every cookie and tart instigating from the pasticceris, Marcello greets you by name, as does Luca Di Vita, the co-owner and sommelier who can introduce his dishes and cellar in six different languages, should you require it, while the chef and other owner, Bruno Gavaguin, peers out from his little kitchen. The menu, which often changes several times a day, is the result of the morning's foray into the Rialto, the famous Venetian marketplace, where their personal fishmonger recommends the catches of the day - no farm-raised seafood is used. All spices and herbs used are grown on the lagoon islands surrounding Venice, the pasta is handmade by Luca's wife Anna, Bruno's mama bakes the cakes, Bruno takes care of the spoon desserts, and Luca and Anna create the ice creams and semi-freddos. Luca, of course, traverses the Veneto to find the fine wines he proudly pours.
Bruno and Luca have been friends "from ever" (actually, 25 years), having known each other from time in the army. Luca attributes this to the fact that "Venice is a very small town." Years in the hotel business have groomed Luca into the suavest, most stylish and most gracious host you could desire, while Bruno's restaurant experience makes him passionate about quality with a dash of creativity and an eye on tradition. Between them, they have been always "been surrounded by tourists and we still love them! (joke)".
How could such extraordinary cuisine feel so comfortable? Bruno's presentations were beyond common but it was like dining with friends who found time to be interested in you and what you thought of their latest creation. The servers, in particular, were almost childishly excited about sharing their feelings about the day's offerings as Luca was assuring in suggesting wine pairings. It's quite too bad I only had room that evening for a main course, dessert and a carafe of the 2007 Monteforche cabernet franc - wait, you mean a wine this good was merely just the house red? Mi dios.
A fish, crustacean and mollusk stew. It was delicate, with flavor awaiting your discovery in each nook and cranny of shell, gill and claw. Unbelievable.
All chocolate cakes that are way too rich, sweet and overpoweringly decadent are impostors. This is the real deal that lets the cacao do the talking as the fondant serves as supporting act and the sauce and accoutrements as symphony. Brava, Madama Gavaguin!
So, of all the seafood joints, in all the towns, in all the world, I walk back into Luca and Bruno's the next night. I resisted the pasticceri trappings and Rialto fresh produce all day, so I could have a proper Venetian meal at their table. When I returned for yet another 7pm seating, Marcello greeted me by name. I quickly learned that it only takes one meal at Alle Testiere to give you "old friend" status. They remembered what I ate the night before, so they could make new recommendations. They didn't even ask me what kind of wine I was in the mood for. They just knew what I should have, which of course turned out to be exactly what I wanted. It was a 2008 Ca'emo from La Montecchia, and mercy if my heart wouldn't rather be pumping these tannins than hemoglobins.
Scallops spectacularly grilled and settled in orange and red onion sauce - delightfully sea-trus.
Howard insisted that I must have a pasta dish. So I did - spaghetti with Bearnaise clams, so refined that you forget there's clarified butter and yolk in there under-handedly forming the backbone of the dish. That al dente in the spaghetti never went away, no matter how long I lingered over the noodles, so unwilling was I to finish it off.
Let me apologize for choosing something as boring as tiramisu for dessert, when there were at least eight other choices. I couldn't help but be curious about how Bruno handled a sweet plate as regular as they came. Well, that tiramisu is Venice in a bowl. As you follow the swirl of dark chocolate taking you deeper and deeper into the marscapone, you encounter a variety of surprising cameos - pretty complex and hard to discern what exactly - but then, instead of hitting rock bottom, you discover the liqueur-soaked biscotti. It was like seeking truth in the heart of a dessert, an axis of ecstasy.
So, why do you not know about Alle Testiere, although the weeks-long reservation list and full seatings each night mean that your and my former ignorance doesn't quite matter?
"We feel lucky we never got the star Michelin," says Luca. "So we can work relaxed and no formality, but seriously!"
All a very ideal recipe for a epiphany of epicurean excellence, with the perfect pairing...
"Bruno doesn't drink, that is why he is the perfect partner. Always sharp, clear, and he can drive you anywhere! ha ha ha!"
A presto, e grazie.
Photo courtesy of http://www.osterialletestiere.it/.








